Is imaginative work labour in a material sense? Is the artist a lumpen? Or is art properly an elitism, an activity to be subsumed into hobby or propaganda within a socialist project? Is it that we imagine a future classless society has relieved humanity of the burden to write? Granted we understand the dangers of bureaucratic mechanisms of domination; of the mass psychological manipulative power of aesthetic spectacle; that the answer to this problem of Civilization consists in passing off the responsibility for these daemons to a calculated Kubrickian machine, seems, to one so debased as myself still using a pen to form compositions, kind of dubious. When we analyse the imagination through a material lens we can demystify the faculty by understanding it as a process through which potentiality is realised in actuality. Considering the proper goal of the use of imagination in art, if we accept this to be the production of commodities; works or objects of commercial or attention-economic value; then it becomes no real concern to pass off this black box of the creative process to mechanisms of artificiality; that is to say, those that do not arise out of nature, or Humanity, but rather from the dominant tools of our 21st century. To accept that art is useless unless commodified or prioritising its intrinsic value holds no radical potential however is to wave the white flag in the face of a relentless but not immortal onslaught of commanding Alienation. In the scope of technological innovation producing societal advancements during the relatively short period civilisation has been around compared to the emergence of humanity, one shouldn’t be too hard-pressed to find examples of pioneering movements or vanguards that demonstrate in the chronology of progress that not exactly every leap forward is linearly what it claims. Limiting ourselves to the 21st century we do have specific examples of butterfly-effect-like ironic outcomes either accidental or deliberately Orwellian in the paradoxical repercussions for instance of “social” media having resulted in unprecedented interpersonal fracturing, extreme isolation and the institutionalising of colossal antisociality. We remain as though boomers oblivious to the reality that narcotics can be used in programs of social control not to see this.
In a similar manner to how if one viewed the historical emergence of the State as categorically no different than the invention of the wheel, they’d likely not be an anarchist; viewing the onset of artificial intelligence into the domain of our creative processes as no more than the next avant-garde, runs the risk of overlooking how this crossroads of AI likely parallels far more the historical possibility of the State than it does a basic step into modernity. The State is more akin to a way of being than it is a mode of production. If generative AI becomes widespread adopted by artists it seems clear the primary reason will be almost exclusively due to its granting of competitive edge. Not only will such an edge generally only ever be fleetingly quantitative and not lastingly qualitative, seeking edges belongs to the capitalist mode of being; the same type of incentive structure that sees you being played against an older worker today, then tomorrow slapped by your own redundancy. But indulging the capitalist myth of meritocratic validation for a moment, it also seems easily unfathomable that increasingly automated creative processes could actually lead to future artworks admired in sufficiently high demand. An equivalent analogy might be the dubious hope that by flooding the market with sex robots one might expect to see a rebirth of natural human intimacy. Change of a qualitative nature appears more likely to arise out of the conditioning effect which will shape new expectations and perceptions about the experience, in this case, art, which we are already conditioned to consume, as we are conditioned to consume commodities.
In my vision the odds appear heavily weighted towards the future success of generative AI in art production effectively requiring an overall decline in artistic literacy. But, only those gigs in need of artistic talent for work that was, ultimately, categorically commercial is what generative AI now stands to dominate. Ironically this opens the window for a renaissance of counter-hegemonic artistic activity to emerge. The mechanisms of capitalist economics are not only based on exploitation but also function as conditioning processes that assure all its moving parts continue to reproduce this structure. While the end goal of a process drives an agent to achieve their aim, the way success is achieved shapes habit and the capacities available to the agent at the start of the following iteration. According to the same logic do we assert that those who seek to abolish the State will surely fail to do so by continuing to act like a State. Bypassing the question of what is the proper goal of imaginative labour we have previously asserted that the process of the imagination is a move from potentiality to actuality. Outsourcing this process to a machine cannot be expected to strengthen the imaginative capacities of the wielder of the tool any more than use of automated translation software could be expected to train fluency in a second language.
Moreover the interpretation of art is the dialectical twin of its creation. The critic is a poet as much as the poet is a critic. It follows that art based on artificial creation would lead to increasingly artificial interpretations. Assuming the proper goal of art is to produce commodities is indicative of the capitalist conditioning process. Incorporating AI into creativity is the apotheosis of this process. AI itself learns only through conditioning; its entire being could be described as a pure result of the conditioning process, and as such, it lacks in totality an imagination proper. The imagination is spontaneous, free; in degrees unmoored from conditioning, largely an intrinsic phenomenon; whereas conditioning is rigid, rote, extrinsic. Artificial Imagination will only ever be capable of producing novel possibilities through iteration of previous models, biasing the structure against the type of radical breaks required to truly revolutionise society. The trajectory of a future informed by AI appears determined by regression. This is the last stop before entry into a new world whose construction was observed back in the ancient days of 1963 by the Situationist International as “the cybernetic state. . . the technocratic feudalism that is now constituting itself.”1 The text called All The King’s Men draws an opposition similar to the one I’m attempting here between language controlled by power and Poetry, free, authentic language; “direct communication within reality and as real alteration of this reality.” The dynamic of conditioning in opposition to imagination should be understood as dialectical struggle; they cannot exist in equilibrium, one must assert itself over the other. Greater degrees of conditioning produce higher centralisation, more susceptibility to coercive ideologies of authoritarianism, whereas prioritising the intrinsic value of imaginative agency enables higher degrees of coordinated spontaneous radical action.
Revisiting All The King’s Men and the Situationists with their theories of art and politics in general seems like socially-necessary labour for anyone engaged in radical art, political avant-garde or this present question regarding the implementation of artificial intelligence into the creative process. While an analysis of the present circumstances informed by a return to a movement like Situationism would likely require a critique of its economism; perhaps a re-framing such as through David Graeber’s theory of anthropological value; it seems an extremely important centre of gravity of the movement that should be propped up is its tireless call for the abolition of alienation, a position that in recent decades would appear to have been forgotten and even reversed, among factions of radical leftists or intellectuals, often Marxists, and some of whom even stake careers on the contrarian position that alienation were inevitable or desirable. The prospect of uncritically embracing AI as the next acceleration reminds me of such a position. For becoming conditioned on this next and maybe final technological rupture means that imaginative material will no longer primarily gesticulate in the human mind, an ideological interface with biological reality, but rather will draw increasingly from a well of the purely ideological. Artificial imagination is thus the coming alienation of creative labour. We should therefore go back out into the solitude of nature as it were, a prolonged distance from the parasitic magnetism of our ubiquitous screens, and truly contemplate—for however much longer we will authentically retain such a capacity—how much AI could in fact be the intelligence-agency manufactured LSD of this era.
A. Scott Buch
Buch is a poet, novelist, and poker player by necessity. His work exists freely in cyberspace.
1All The King’s Men, Ken Knabb translation, Situationist International Anthology (Revised and Expanded Edition, 2006). [https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/situationist-international-all-the-king-s-men]

